Archimedes on the sphere and cylinder

Max Dehn (1878–1952) said that Archimedes’ (c. 287–212 BCE) discovery that the surface area of a sphere was four times its great circle was the one of the most beautiful results of Greek mathematics.

Archimedes himself had a high opinion of this result and two others in his two books On the Sphere and the Cylinder: that the volume and surface area of a sphere and a cylinder exactly circumscribing it are in the ratio $2 : 3$. One can add a cone fitting inside the cylinder to have ratios $1 : 2 : 3$ (see diagram).

Diagram showing a cylinder circumscribing a sphere and a cone. The base of the cone is the base of the cylinder, and their heights are equal.

It has been suggested that Archimedes’ conjectures for these ratios may have been guided by a conscious or unconscious search for beautiful integer ratios between geometric configurations. There is no direct evidence for this motivation, but Archimedes’ work seems to exhibit a preference for small integer ratios.

According to Plutarch, Archimedes desired that his tomb should be marked by a cylinder enclosing a sphere and an inscription of the ratio of the one to the other; Cicero related how he had sought out Archimedes’ tomb and found a column just so inscribed.

Paolo Barbotti's painting ‘Cicero discovering the tomb of Archimedes’ (1853). Cicero is depicted with a group of other people, old and young. He is gesturing towards a square pillar marking the tomb of Archimedes, near the top of which is carved a diagram showing a cylinder circumscribing a sphere and a cone.

References

Image credits

« Apollonius of Perga on beautiful theorems
Nicon, the sphere, the cylinder, and Pantheon »